Ya’ll I am SHOOK!!! How have I lived this long w/o knowing about tubing mascara!!! I’ve tried every designer mascara & this tops them all. This is a game changer. The formula does not smudge👏🏼flake👏🏼or 👏🏼clump!! Alllll day!! It also makes lashes look like individual strand false lashes. I’m obsessed & never going back. LTKMostLoved LTKstyletip LTKbeauty