Which of these 3 self tanners is the best imo? Beauty by earth- wasn't dark enough for me. Took over 8 hours to develop. Literally could barely tell I had self tanned. Only lasted roughly 3 days. There definitely was a self tanner smell. It is made with lots of natural ingredients. Peta Jane- worked well enough. Took over 8 hours to develop. Lasted around 5-6 days. Should've went darker. Didn't really have that self tanner smell. Loving tan- DEVELOPED IN 2 HOURS! Definitely dark enough for me. Lasted around 7-8 days. A little bit of the self tanner smell. The winner is... Loving Tan! Definitely impressed with it! LTKBeauty LTKSwim LTKSummerEdit