The yellow eyelet top fit me best in a size large. I took a medium in the dolman henleys. They fit very oversized so I recommend sizing down. The sandals run true to size for me, super comfortable on my feet. I do not have narrow feet either. The gold hardware near the toes does not dig into the foot at all and the strap between the toes is not uncomfortable. I love these and am considering getting them in yellow too. LTKStyleTip LTKMidsize LTKSaleAlert