I bought both so you don't have to. The Coach Chelsea and the Tory Burch Charlie — everyone's calling them sisters, but are they really? Here's what nobody tells you: the Coach has that natural full grain leather that actually gets better with age and has an additional suede lining. The Tory Burch Charlie? diamond quilting that photographs insanely well, and a classy elevated vibe. Price breakdown: Coach Chelsea runs around $325-350 depending on the straps. Tory Burch Charlie sits at $595. That's a $250-$270 gap for what a lot of people are calling "basically the same bag." My verdict? If you want something more casual and to save some money, the Chelsea is where it’s at! If you want something more elevated and versatile then the Charlie is a great choice. Which one would you pick? Comment COACH or TORY and tell me why — I'm genuinely curious where people land on this one. Follow for more bag comparisons!