These were the top rated! We have my toddlers in the Evenflo Revolve 360 Extend (rear facing up to 50lbs!) that was my selling point. Highest rear facing weight limit. The Emme is pretty and nice but be cautious - after a month of use the rotating feature wouldn’t lock in place and my kids could kick the seat and rotate themself. They did exchange for new seats no problem and I haven’t had issues with new seats. The Graco is only 180 but works just the same. You may have to reinstall other direction when you want to switch to forward facing. Maxi-Cosi seems to also get grown out of quicker than other car seats - keep in mind if you have bigger kiddos/ taller kiddos like I do LTKFamily LTKKids LTKBaby